Insights / News
Insights / News
The appeal was related to the case of Secretary of State for the Home Department & others v Sargeant  EWCA Civ 2844;  ICR 1489, in which Andrew and Lydia acted for over 6,000 firefighters who claimed that the decision to exclude them from their pension scheme in circumstances in which their older colleagues were allowed to remain in them, was age discrimination. Those claims were upheld by the Court of Appeal against both the government and the FRAs, and permission to appeal that decision to the Supreme Court was denied in June 2019.
Following those decisions, the FRAs argued that they should not be liable for the claims – that they were simply implementing the government’s decisions. These decisions took the form of a statutory instrument containing the rules of the pension scheme, and in applying those rules they were acting ‘pursuant to an enactment’, such that there was a defence under paragraph 1 of Schedule 22 of the Equality Act.
The EAT rejected that argument, holding (amongst other things) that:
Read the full judgment in the case of London Fire Commissioner Others v Ms R Sargeant Others here.
Andrew Short QC has a highly respected employment practice which covers everything from complex or sensitive dismissal and discrimination cases through TUPE to high value contract, restrictive covenant, fiduciary duty and equal pay claims. He has acted in many of the leading cases relating to discrimination in pay and pensions, including Abdulla v Birmingham City Council, Brierley v Asda, and McCloud v Lord Chancellor, and Sargeant v LFEPA. Find out more about Andrew’s practice and recent cases here.
Lydia Seymour has over twenty years’ experience of all aspects of employment and discrimination law. She has specialised in complex discrimination claims (including claims at the interface of pensions and employment law) and High Court bonus and restrictive covenant issues. As well as acting on a number of claims raising issues of age discrimination and pension entitlement (including claims relating to transitional provisions in scheme amendments and redundancy), she has acted in a number of high profile claims brought by senior women working in the city alleging structural sex discrimination in relation to bonus payments and promotion. Find out more about Lydia’s practice here.
For a confidential discussion regarding any employment law or discrimination matter please contact Nicholas Levett, Practice Director, on +44 (0)207 427 4908.